Best Baby Teething Toys: 6 Safe Picks for Sore Gums
TL;DR: Quick summaryThe best baby teething toys are soft, one piece silicone teethers that are too big to swallow, easy to wash, and cooled in the fridge rather than the freezer. A clean chilled washcloth works too. Skip teething necklaces and anything that can break into small p
In this article
TL;DR: Quick summary
The best baby teething toys are soft, one piece silicone teethers that are too big to swallow, easy to wash, and cooled in the fridge rather than the freezer. A clean chilled washcloth works too. Skip teething necklaces and anything that can break into small pieces, and always watch your baby while they chew.
What you'll get
About 25 minutes to read. Short on time? Read the bold lines and the Key Takeaways near the end.
It is 3 in the morning. Your baby is drooling through a fourth bib, gnawing on a fist, and furious about it. You grab whatever is closest, maybe a car key or the TV remote, and then you stop and wonder what is actually safe to put in that mouth.
If that sounds familiar, this article is for you. I have answered this question in clinic more times than I can count, and the answer is simpler than the shopping aisle makes it look. We will cover when teething starts, what makes a teether safe, how to cool one properly, and which kinds suit which babies.
I should be honest up front. A teething toy will not make teething disappear, and no product makes it painless. A good one gives your baby something safe to bite on, and gives you a calmer evening. Let's make sure you choose well.
When does teething start, and is it really the teeth?
Teething usually starts between four and seven months, though some babies start earlier or well after their first birthday. Typical signs are drooling, chewing and mild fussiness. A high fever, diarrhea or a runny nose is more likely a virus than teething.
How early or late can it start?
Most babies get their first tooth somewhere in the middle of the first year. The American Academy of Pediatrics puts it simply:
Teething usually starts between four and seven months.
American Academy of Pediatrics, HealthyChildren.org
The NHS adds that most babies start teething at around 6 months, but others start before they are 4 months old and some after 12 months. So if your friend's baby has a tooth at four months and yours has none at ten, that is usually just normal variety.
Picture a five month old who suddenly drools through every outfit and shoves both fists in her mouth. Her parents wonder if teeth are coming. They might be, but babies also chew because they are exploring, so drooling and mouthing alone do not prove it.
What does teething actually look like?
Teething occasionally may cause mild irritability and a slight rise in temperature, but not over 101 degrees Fahrenheit. Some parents also notice sore, red gums, a damp chin and a baby who wants to chew on everything. Gums may look a little puffy or red where a tooth is pushing up.
Here is the part that matters most. Johns Hopkins Medicine says it clearly:
If your child is having fevers greater than 101, diarrhea or runny nose, it’s likely due to a virus and not due to teething.
Johns Hopkins Medicine
Signs that point away from teething and toward something else:
If you see any of these, do not put it down to "just teething". Call your doctor or health visitor.
Why a teething toy helps
When a tooth is pushing through, chewing gives the gums firm, steady counter pressure. That is why your baby suddenly bites everything. A teether gives that urge a safe target.
The FDA suggests that if a child's gums are swollen and tender, you can gently rub or massage the gums with your finger. That costs nothing and is a good first step before you buy anything. A toy is a helper, not a cure.
Common mistakes at this stage:
A quick word on tone. Many parents feel guilty when nothing seems to soothe a baby. Teething is uncomfortable, it comes in waves, and it passes, so a few rough evenings do not mean you are doing it wrong.
What makes a teething toy safe?
A safe teether is one solid piece, too big to swallow, firm but not rock hard, and free of anything that can snap off. Check the size with a toilet paper roll, and stay close while your baby chews. Stay with your baby whenever they are using any teether.
Size and shape
Choking is a serious risk with any baby toy. KidsHealth says it is a hazard for kids ages 3 or younger, because they tend to put objects in their mouths. A teether that looks big in your hand can still be dangerous if a piece comes off.
KidsHealth gives clear size guidance for baby toys: at least 1¼ inches (3 centimeters) in diameter and 2¼ inches (6 centimeters) in length, so they cannot be swallowed or lodged in the throat. A small parts tester, or choke tube, can determine if a toy is too small. If you cannot find one, a toilet paper roll can be used for the same purpose.
Here is the home test. If the toy, or any piece that could come off it, fits all the way inside the tube, it is too small for a baby.
Baby Teething Toys 3-6 Months, Baby Chew Teether Toys
- Safety: Food grade silicone, BPA free, Toxin Free. Easy to clean and disinfect.(WARNING:Adult supervision is…
- Teething Relief & Easy to Clean: Relieve the discomfort of baby's teething gums, will also help with sensory…
- 4 Pack Variety Design: Your infant will get 4 teething toys in different colors and shapes in this pack, and…
Hardness and construction
KidsHealth also recommends this:
Make sure it's big enough that it can't be swallowed or choked on and that it can't break into small pieces.
KidsHealth
Hardness matters too. The FDA warns:
If the object is too hard, it can hurt the child’s gums. Be sure to supervise children so they don’t accidentally choke on the teething ring.
FDA
This is why I like soft, bendy silicone. It gives enough resistance to push against, but it yields.
What do labels really tell you?
Labels reassure, but they are not a guarantee. In the US, the Consumer Product Safety Commission covers teethers and teething toys intended to soothe a child but not to ease teething pain. A product primarily intended to soothe teething pain falls outside the CPSC's jurisdiction.
You do not need to memorize that. The point is that safety rules can depend on how a maker words its claims, so you still need to do your own checks. Words like "BPA free" and "food grade" tell you about the material, not about size or breakage.
Your quick safety checklist before any teether goes in a mouth:
Common mistakes:
One more point: your baby's size and skills change fast. A toy that was fine at four months might be a different story once your baby can pull pieces apart with strong fingers. Re-check your toys regularly, especially as your baby grows.
Should I chill or freeze a teether?
Chill it in the refrigerator, but do not freeze it. Mayo Clinic advises chilling teething rings or wet washcloths in the fridge, and the FDA notes that a toy that is too hard can hurt gums. A cool, firm but yielding teether is the goal.
Why fridge and not freezer?
Cold feels good on sore, swollen gums. It numbs a little and calms the area. The trouble with the freezer is that a frozen toy turns rock hard, and as we saw, a toy that is too hard can hurt the gums.
Mayo Clinic is blunt about it:
Chill teething rings, pacifiers, or wet washcloths in the refrigerator. Do not freeze them.
Mayo Clinic
Some silicone teethers are sold as freezer safe, which only tells you the toy itself can handle the cold. But "safe for the toy" is not the same as "ideal for your baby's gums". My advice is to follow the fridge rule even when the packet says freezer is fine.
Your sixth option: the humble washcloth
Honestly, one of the best teething toys costs nothing. Wet a clean washcloth, wring it out, fold it or twist it into a rope, and chill it in the fridge. Hold one end while your baby chews the other.
Here is how to do it:
- Wash your hands and use a clean, soft washcloth.
- Wet it with cool water and wring it out well.
- Fold or twist it and place it in a clean container in the fridge.
- Offer it after a short chill, holding on to one end the whole time.
- Wash the cloth after each use.
You hold on because a cloth can be pulled into the mouth or bunched up. The chill is gentle and the texture is nice for gnawing.
Choosing a fridge friendly teether
If you prefer a ready made teether, you can chill the Frida silicone teether in the fridge.
Mayo Clinic advises chilling teethers in the fridge and not freezing them, and the FDA notes that a toy that is too hard can hurt a child's gums.
Frida Silicone Teething Toys, 4-in-1 Teether for Babies & Infants
- COMFY TO HOLD: The teether's silicone handle does not get cold, so a baby can hold on while the chilled…
- FOUR TEXTURED SURFACES: Two gel-filled inserts fit into the handle, with a different shape on each side. That…
- REFRIGERATE ONLY: Cool the inserts in the refrigerator only. Frida advises against the freezer because…
What about gel inside a teether?
This is a fair question, and I want to be straight with you. Mayo Clinic suggests this:
Make sure any teething rings are filled with distilled water instead of gel in case your baby's new teeth put a hole in a ring.
Mayo Clinic
The AAP also notes that plastic teething rings with liquids have been given a bad name in the past few years. So with any gel or liquid filled teether, inspect it closely every single time. If you see a crack, a dent or a leak, bin it.
Press the insert, look for cracks, and discard at the first sign of damage.
Common mistakes:
What are the best teethers for the youngest babies?
For babies who are just starting to teethe, choose a light, simple silicone teether that a small fist can hold, such as the Arudyo silicone rudder teether or the HAILI XMGQ set. Both are easy to clean. Check each one for cracks before every use, and keep your eyes on your baby.
A light, hollow ring for first chewers
The Arudyo teether pairs silicone with natural beech wood. Its silicone rudder shape is sized so it is hard to swallow, and its hollow design keeps it very light. That matters for young babies, who tire quickly and drop heavy things on their own faces.
The listing says it can also be used for grasping practice as babies get older. I like that idea, because chewing and grasping develop together. Your baby is learning to bring things to their mouth on purpose.
Baby Teething Toys Silicone Teethers BPA Free Silicone Rudder with Wooden Ring Soothe Babies Gums (Khaki)
- SAFE MATERIAL – 100% food grade silicone and natural beech. The size of this silicone rudder teether is…
- HIGH TEMPERATURE – Our silicone rudder can withstand a high temperature of 200 degrees, so you can wash it…
- SOOTHE GUMS – This teething ring has a hollow design, is lightweight and has a suitable size, which is very…
Cleaning it properly
The silicone part of the Arudyo rudder can handle high heat, according to the listing. Clean the silicone part by boiling or steam disinfection, following the listing. The wooden ring cannot be boiled, so wipe that part clean instead.
Look at the wooden ring regularly. Wood can dry out, crack or roughen over time, and any splinter or rough patch means it is time to retire the toy. If your baby chews hard enough to damage it, switch to an all silicone option.
A set with variety
If you like having options, the HAILI XMGQ pack gives you four silicone teethers in different colors and shapes: a giraffe, a peach, a grape and a banana toothbrush teether. The listing says they support boiling or steam disinfection and have a smooth surface that is simple to rinse. A set means one can be in use, one in the fridge and one in the wash.
Picture a four month old who loves the banana shape for the front gums and prefers the grape for the back. Giving a baby two or three shapes lets you find out what they actually like. Babies are surprisingly picky.
How to introduce a teether
Do not expect a four month old to know what to do. Show them. Put the toy in their hands, guide it to their mouth, and let them explore.
- Wash the toy and let it dry.
- Sit with your baby in good light so you can see their face.
- Place the toy in their hand and help it find their mouth.
- Stay in the room and keep watching.
- Take the toy away if it cracks, if your baby gags repeatedly, or if they fall asleep chewing it.
Common mistakes with first teethers:
Teething often arrives alongside other changes. Sleep may get patchy and your baby may seem clingier. That does not mean you have to give up on the plan.
Do teething mittens and fruit sets help babies who drop everything?
Yes, for many babies. A mitten stays on the hand, so there is nothing to drop, which suits babies who cannot hold a teether yet. A multipack of fruit shapes suits babies who can grip and like variety. Neither replaces watching your baby.
Why a mitten works for the youngest
Very young babies often cannot hold a teether and bring it to their mouth. They flail, the toy hits the floor, and they cry louder. A mitten solves the dropping problem by staying on.
The ChooKaChoo teething mitten is a soft silicone mitten that fits over little hands. An inner bar gives extra grip, and the listing says it protects babies from chewing on their hand, but supervise your baby with any teether. Check the listing for the age it is sold for and how many come in the pack.
2 Pack Baby Teething Toy Silicone Teething Mitten for Babies Over 3 Months Anti Dropping Wrist Hand Teethers Baby Chew Toys for Sucking Needs, BPA Free
- Give your little one a hand with teething: The Silicone Teething Mitten is the perfect solution for babies…
- Textured Surface Comforts Sore gums: The teether mitten features soft and durable textures of the bumps and…
- Food Grade Soft Silicone: Teethers are made of BPA free silicone with no small part to provide a strong, yet…
Fit matters
A mitten should be snug enough to stay on but not tight. Check your baby's wrist and fingers each time you put it on. If you see red marks, swelling or a pale hand, take it off and try a different size or toy.
The listing describes textured bumps and lumps and a design that mimics a nipple to soothe fussy babies. Many babies like that familiar shape. The maker also says it has no small part, but check it yourself every time, and look for tears around the bar.
A set of fruit shaped teethers
Once your baby can grip, a multipack gives variety. The YIYEE six pack of fruit teethers gives you six soft silicone pieces in different fruit shapes. Each shape has different textures, so your baby can explore with the gums and mouth.
The listing calls them dishwasher and freezer safe. As we covered, I would still use the fridge, not the freezer, for the gums' sake. Their light weight and varied shapes make them good for babies who like to compare things.
Which is better for my baby?
Use this quick guide:
Sitting is a handy milestone here. Once babies can sit steadily, both hands are free to explore, and teethers become much easier to use. If you want to help that along, help your baby learn to sit up with plenty of supported floor time.
Picture a four month old in a bouncer who keeps dropping a ring and howling. A parent puts a mitten on her, and for once the toy stays put. She chews on it for ten minutes and then settles.
Common mistakes:
How do I clean teething toys and spot a worn out one?
Wash teethers after every use with warm soapy water, or follow the maker's cleaning instructions, and check them for cracks, tears or loose parts before each use. Throw away any damaged teether, and keep an eye out for recalls.
A simple cleaning routine
Teethers spend a lot of time in a mouth, on the floor and in a bag. A quick wash after each use keeps things simple. Always follow the instructions on the packaging, because materials differ.
Many silicone teethers can handle more than you would think. Check each listing, such as the YIYEE six pack and the HAILI XMGQ set, for the maker's cleaning method before you wash. Check the ChooKaChoo mitten listing for the maker's cleaning method before you wash it.
Baby Teething Toys 6 Packs BPA Free Silicone Baby Teethers, Freezer Safe Organic Infant Teething Toys Soft & Textured for Natural Brain Development
- 100% Safe & Comfortable for Baby: Our baby teething toys are professionally made of soft and chewable food…
- Happy Satisfaction From Teething Relief: These infant teething toys are designed to soothe, massage gums and…
- Attractive Cute Fruit Design: In this pack, there is 6 teething toys with different fruit designs and shapes…
Here is a routine that works for most families:
- Rinse the teether right after use to remove saliva and food.
- Wash it with warm soapy water or follow the maker's method.
- For teethers that allow it, boil or steam them from time to time.
- Air dry on a clean surface.
- Store in a clean container, not loose in a nappy bag.
Remember the exception: check the maker's instructions before boiling any teether with wooden parts, such as the Arudyo teether. Follow the maker's listed boiling time for the silicone part, and do not guess. Wipe the wood with a damp cloth.
When to throw one away
Teethers wear out. Gums are gentle, but new teeth can bite hard, and silicone can tear or thin. Discard a teether at once if any part becomes loose, cracked or broken, and that is a good rule for every teether.
Retire a teether if you notice:
Recalls are real
Teething toys do get recalled. A health alert round up from AAP News listed a recall of 49,410 AiTuiTui Pull String Teething Toys, among other products. You do not need to memorize recall lists. You do need to know that it happens, and that toys with pull strings or cords deserve extra caution.
Check the brand and model name when you buy, and search the CPSC recall page now and then. If a toy is recalled, stop using it right away and follow the instructions in the notice. It is worth doing even with toys that were gifts.
Picture a parent whose seven month old has had the same teether since month four. It looks fine, but under a bright light there is a tiny tear near the edge. That is the moment to replace it, not to wait for a bigger break.
Common mistakes:
What should I skip, and when should I call the doctor?
Skip teething necklaces, bracelets and any jewelry on a baby; the AAP does not recommend that infants wear any. Call your doctor if your baby has a fever above 101 degrees Fahrenheit or seems truly unwell, since a fever above that, diarrhea or a runny nose are likely due to a virus rather than teething.
Why teething jewelry is a hard no
Amber necklaces, beads and bracelets are sold as natural teething remedies. The risks are serious. The AAP does not recommend that infants wear any jewelry.
The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) does not recommend that infants wear any jewelry.
American Academy of Pediatrics, HealthyChildren.org
AAP News, summarizing an FDA warning, reports that the FDA has received reports of children choking on beads that break off, and of an 18 month old being strangled to death by an amber necklace. A string around a baby's neck is a strangling risk, and beads can break and be swallowed. I would not make an exception, even if the necklace is worn only while awake.
What to say when someone gives you one
This comes up in clinic all the time, because grandparents and friends mean well. Here are words you can use:
"Thank you so much, that's so thoughtful. Our paediatrician has said no jewelry for babies at all, because of choking and strangling risks, so we can't use it. Could we swap it for something else? We'd love a soft silicone teether."
Keep it kind and short. You are not criticizing the giver, you are following the safety advice. Most people understand when you put it that way.
Other things to skip
For medicines and rubs, ask your doctor or health visitor what is suitable for your baby's age and weight, and ask them for the correct dose. I will not give doses in an article, because they depend on your baby.
When to call the doctor
Teething is a mild, passing nuisance. These signs mean something else may be going on:
If you are worried, trust that feeling and call. It is always fine to ask, and a quick call can save a lot of anxiety.
Getting through the nights
Teething can make babies more fretful and disturb their sleep, and nights can feel harder when there is nothing else to distract your baby. A cool washcloth, a gentle gum rub and a quiet, dim room can help. Some parents find steady sound helps settle a fussy baby, and there is a good explanation in why white noise works.
Be careful about creating new habits at 3 in the morning. If you are curious about the trade offs, read about rocking your baby to sleep before you decide what to do on the hardest nights.
Picture a parent at 2 a.m. with a baby who has been grizzling for hours and feels warm. A quick check shows a temperature above 101 degrees Fahrenheit and a runny nose. That is a call to the doctor, not another teething toy.
Which teething toy should I pick? A quick comparison
Use this table to match a toy to your baby's stage. Age ranges are loose, because babies vary a lot. For any product, always read the maker's age guidance.
| Option | Best Age Range | Primary Benefits | Main Drawbacks | Recommended Product | Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Silicone and beech wood rudder teether | From about 3 months | Light, hollow, easy to grip, simple shape | Wooden ring cannot be boiled | Arudyo silicone rudder teether | $7.95 |
| Six pack of fruit shaped teethers | Once baby can grip and pass things | Variety of shapes and textures, easy to rotate | More pieces to wash and track | YIYEE six pack teethers | $8.99 |
| Fridge cooled insert teether | Once baby can hold a handle | Handle stays comfortable while insert cools; four textured surfaces | Gel filled inserts need close checking; fridge only | Frida silicone teether | $9.99 |
| Silicone teething mitten | From about 3 months | Stays on the hand, so nothing to drop | Needs a good fit; check the wrist | ChooKaChoo teething mitten | $9.99 |
| Four pack of shaped silicone teethers | From about 3 months | Boil or steam cleaning, fun shapes, good for rotating | Discard if any part cracks or loosens | HAILI XMGQ teether set | $8.99 |
The sixth option, a chilled wet washcloth, is covered by the cooling advice above, so it is not in the table. Keep one chilled in your fridge as a backup, but do not freeze it.
Frequently asked questions
Key Takeaways
- Teething usually starts between four and seven months, but some babies start earlier or later, so watch your baby's cues rather than the calendar.
- A safe teether is one solid piece, bigger than a toilet paper roll's opening, soft enough not to hurt gums, and free of strings or beads.
- Chill teethers in the refrigerator and do not freeze them. A wet, chilled washcloth is a good free option.
- Silicone options like the Arudyo teether, HAILI XMGQ set and YIYEE six pack suit babies who can hold things, and the ChooKaChoo mitten suits babies who drop everything.
- Check every teether for cracks and loose parts before each use, and throw away any that are damaged. Keep an eye out for recalls.
- Do not use teething necklaces or any jewelry on a baby.
- A fever above 101 degrees Fahrenheit, diarrhea or a runny nose is likely due to a virus and not teething, so call your doctor.
A last word
Teething is one of those stages that feels endless in the middle of the night and is forgotten a few months later. You do not need a drawer full of gadgets. You need a few safe, simple things, a cold washcloth, and a calm adult who stays close.
Safe, simple and supervised beats fancy every time. If this guide helped, save it for the next sleepless evening, share it with a partner or grandparent, and come back to tinymindsworld.com whenever you have another question. You are doing better than you think.
Sources & References
- HealthyChildren.org (AAP). "When Does Teething Start? - HealthyChildren.org."
- NHS. "Baby teething symptoms - NHS."
- Johns Hopkins Medicine. "What You Should Know about Babies Teething."
- fda.gov. "Topical Drugs and Teething Jewelry Used for Teething Have Risks."
- mayoclinic.org. "Teething: Tips for soothing sore gums - Mayo Clinic."
- HealthyChildren.org, American Academy of Pediatrics. "How to Help Teething Symptoms without Medications - HealthyChildren.org."
- kidshealth.org. "Teething Tots."
- kidshealth.org. "Choosing Safe Toys for Babies."
- kidshealth.org. "Choosing Safe Toys for Toddlers and Preschoolers."
- HealthyChildren.org, American Academy of Pediatrics. "Teething Necklaces and Beads: A Caution for Parents - HealthyChildren.org."
- American Academy of Pediatrics. "FDA: Teething necklaces can lead to choking, strangulation."
- American Academy of Pediatrics. "Health alerts: Baby loungers, teething toys, crib bumpers, and more."
- cpsc.gov. "Teethers and Teething Toys."
Frequently Asked Questions
At what age should I give my baby a teething toy?
Can I freeze teething toys?
Are teething necklaces safe?
Does teething cause a fever?
How do I know if a teether is too small?
Can I give my baby something to chew that is not a teether?
Was this helpful?
Thanks — your feedback helps us pick what to write next.























