Tiny Minds World

Early School-Age

The Sharenting Debate: Privacy Risks and Safer Ways to Share

TL;DR: Quick summaryOccasional photo sharing is not wrong, but it needs thought. Post to a small private circle, leave out their school, location and anything embarrassing, and ask them first if they are old enough to answer. Their yes or no is practice for the privacy choices th

By 26 min read
The Sharenting Debate: Privacy Risks and Safer Ways to Share
In this article

TL;DR: Quick summary

Occasional photo sharing is not wrong, but it needs thought. Post to a small private circle, leave out their school, location and anything embarrassing, and ask them first if they are old enough to answer. Their yes or no is practice for the privacy choices they will make later.

By age 13, parents will on average have posted 1,300 photos and videos of their child, so small habits add up.
Names, school, location and any photo of a child in a state of nudity are the details to keep out of public posts.
Over half of parents do not seek their children's permission before sharing content about them. Asking before you post builds trust and teaches your child about consent.
You can tidy up old posts at any time, and from around 9 to 10 your child can help you do it.

What you'll get

A clear sense of which posts are low risk and which ones belong offline
Exact words to use when you talk to your child, your partner, grandparents and school
A simple cleanup plan for photos you have already posted

About 20 minutes to read. Short on time? Read the bold lines and the Key Takeaways near the end.

By the time a child turns 13, their parents will have posted, on average, 1,300 photos and videos of them online. Nobody decides on that number. It builds up one first day of school picture, one birthday video and one funny tantrum at a time.

If your child is young, you are likely in the most active sharing years. There are school events, wobbly teeth, swimming badges and first chapter books. Everything feels worth keeping, and you want the grandparents to see it too.

This guide is for you if you love sharing but have a nagging feeling you should think harder about it. You do not need to delete your accounts or feel guilty. You need a few clear habits. We will look at the real risks, how to bring your child into the decision, what to post and what to skip, how to handle relatives and schools, and how to tidy up what is already out there.

Is sharenting actually bad for my child?

Not by itself. The American Academy of Pediatrics says sharing content of your family online isn't inherently bad or wrong, but it does need thoughtful consideration. What matters is who can see the post, what it reveals, and whether your child would be happy with it later.

Why most of us share

Let's start with the honest part. Parents share because it feels good, and often it does good. You want grandparents on another continent to see the wobbly bike ride. You want another parent to tell you that yes, their child also refuses to wear socks. Posting can make a lonely stretch of parenting feel lighter.

None of that is shameful. I never tell parents to stop taking pictures. I ask them to pause for a second before the picture leaves their phone.

How quickly it adds up

A poll of 2000 UK parents showed they shared around 195 images of their children per year. That is not a parent being careless. It is an ordinary habit, repeated. Those small habits are how a childhood reaches the 1,300 mark.

Many of those images go online long before your child can have a view about them.

Where sharing tips into oversharing

The AAP notes that when photos are shared with a public audience, the practice can create risks like unwanted contact. Researchers also point out that sharing a child's personal information without proper privacy protection can bring privacy risks for the child.

Here is the awkward part. In the United States, no clinical or legal guidelines exist for parents on safe sharing. So the decision really is yours, and you need your own simple rules.

Picture two parents who post the same photo of a child holding a swimming certificate. One sends it to a small private group of relatives. The other posts it publicly and tags the pool. Same proud smile, very different risk.

Common mistakes:

Assuming a private account means nobody else can see the post (followers can still screenshot or reshare)
Posting first and thinking afterwards
Picturing only your friends as the audience, rather than everyone who could possibly find it

Up next: the specific details in a photo that give your child away.

What are the real privacy risks of posting my child's photos?

The main risks are unwanted contact, strangers piecing together your child's identity, and details that show where they are. Photos shared with a public audience can create risks like unwanted contact. Names, school and location are the details that matter most, so guard those first.

The name, school and address trail

Most of the risk comes from small details that look harmless one at a time. Put them together and a stranger can work out who your child is and where to find them.

Posting a first day of school picture can result in people knowing your child's name and where they attend school. A logo on a jumper, a school gate, a bus stop sign or a banner behind a class photo can all say the same thing.

Location clues also hide in medical updates. If you mention the hospital you're staying in, you reveal where you are, which makes it much easier to work out your home address.

Identity details

Scammers can gather information about a child through a parent's social media posts. A full name, a birthday, a hometown and a pet's name are the building blocks. I would not hand those to a stranger in the street, and a public post does much the same thing.

Picture a seven year old on the front step in a school jumper with the crest showing. The caption reads "Day 1 of Year 3, so proud of Mia!" That one post gives a first name, a school, a year group and probably the front door. Nobody meant any harm. It is simply a lot of information in one frame.

Photos that should stay private

Some photos should never be shared, however cute they look. Think of a bath splash, a swimming costume photo, or a child getting changed at the beach. The advice is blunt and I agree with it.

Don’t share images of your children in any state of nudity.

NIH National Library of Medicine

The risk of misuse is the reason these images should always stay private. Keep them on your phone or in a printed album, and enjoy them there.

What the rules say, and what they don't

In the US, COPPA prohibits online data collection without verifiable parental consent for children under 13. That rule is aimed at the companies running online services, not at you posting a photo of your child. If you want to read the text itself, the Children's Online Privacy Protection Rule is available as an ebook.

Rules also differ by country. Italy, for example, sets the age for digital consent at 14. Because there are no US guidelines for parents on safe sharing, your own habits do most of the protecting.

Common mistakes:

Tagging the school, the park, the pool or the football club
Posting live from a place, rather than later from home
Using a full name in a caption
Leaving location tagging switched on in your camera or app

If you want to go further on protecting your family's information, How to Be Invisible is a broader privacy book for adults. It is not about sharenting, but parents who like to tighten up everything at once may find it useful.

Up next: whether you should ask your child before you post.

Should I ask my 6 year old before I post?

Yes, ask. Childnet's advice is to speak to your child before you post a photo or video of them online. At ages 5 to 8 it takes a moment, and it is not about legal permission. It is about teaching your child that their image belongs to them.

Why asking matters when they are so young

Many parents skip this step. De Wolf (2020) found that over half of parents do not seek their children's permission before sharing content about them. In a survey of 1,460 Czech and Spanish parents, around 80% published pictures of their child, and only 20% obtained their child's consent.

You are not a bad parent if you have not asked. Most of us simply never thought to. But by ages 5 to 8, children care a lot about being laughed at, about pyjama photos, and about missing front teeth.

This is also the age when children learn about body boundaries and saying no to a hug. A photo is a small, safe place to practise the same idea: "my picture, my say."

Be honest about what this is

A 6 year old cannot give informed consent to something as complicated as a public online footprint. You are still the one who decides. But listening to your child sends the message that their feelings count, and it sets up the habit you will rely on when they are 10 or 12.

The AAP puts the basic rule in one short line.

If your child is old enough to ask, ask them.

American Academy of Pediatrics

Exact words to use

Keep it short, concrete and light. Try these steps:

  1. Show the photo first: "I love this picture of you at the beach. Can I share it with Grandma and Grandpa?"
  2. Say who will see it: "Only family in our private group. Not strangers."
  3. Offer a real choice: "Yes, no, or ask me later are all fine answers."
  4. Respect the answer and say thanks: "Thanks for telling me. I won't post that one."

What if they say no, or say yes to everything?

If your child says no, accept it without bargaining. A no might mean they feel silly in the photo, or they have a gap in their teeth, or they simply want it kept for the family. Treat that as useful information rather than defiance.

If your child says yes to everything, they may not yet grasp what "online" means. You can say, "Thanks. I'll still keep your name and school out of it." That teaches them that some details stay private even when everybody is happy.

Common mistakes:

Asking only when you expect a yes
Asking after the post has already gone up
Offering a treat for saying yes
Overruling a no "just this once"

Many parents find it easier to teach this alongside body safety. A children's activity book like NO! I'M TELLING! can make the conversation about personal space and boundaries easier for young children to follow. Respecting a child's no is also one of the parenting tips for raising confident kids that matter most.

Up next: a quick test for deciding what is safe to post.

How do I decide what is safe to post?

Run every post through three quick checks: who can see it, what does it reveal, and would your child be fine with it at 13. If any answer worries you, send it privately or skip it. Most posts pass easily, and a few do not.

The three question test

  1. Who can see this? A public post, a list of hundreds of followers and a small private group are three very different audiences.
  2. What does it reveal? Look for a name, a school, a uniform, a street, a routine or a regular place.
  3. Would my child be happy with this at 13? Picture them as a teenager scrolling back through it.

The AAP's HealthyChildren site has a similar list of five questions to ask before you post. You can use mine or theirs. The point is that you stop for a few seconds, every time.

Posts I am usually comfortable with, and posts I would skip

A craft project, with only hands in the picture
A child from behind, looking out at the sea
A reading certificate, with the school name cropped out and sent to a private family group
A family photo sent directly to grandparents after your child has agreed
Anything showing the school name, crest, class group or a school event location
A tagged location, such as the park, the pool or the club
Meltdowns, toilet accidents, illness, and anything your child would find humiliating later
Bath, swimming or getting changed photos

Settings that help

Settings differ by app, so check the menus on yours. Most platforms let you do the following:

Make your account private and review who follows you
Turn off location tagging in the camera and in each app
Stop other people from tagging your child
Limit who can reshare your posts
Use a shared album or direct message instead of a feed

A family media plan

The AAP encourages families to use its Family Media Plan, which can help identify at risk behaviors by both children and caregivers. That is a useful way to think about it. Sharing rules apply to adults as well as children.

If you are building a plan, the screen time limits that actually work article covers practical tools for the child side of it. Then add your own adult rules on posting.

Common mistakes:

Trusting your memory instead of a short routine
Changing your settings once and never checking them again
Assuming that if other parents post it, it must be fine

If you want a family discussion guide on technology, 5 Habits of the Tech Ready Family is written from a Christian perspective, so take what fits your own values and leave the rest.

Up next: what to say to grandparents, schools and other parents.

What do I say to grandparents, schools and other parents who post?

Say it kindly, early and in specific terms. Most relatives and teachers are not careless, they have just never been told what you prefer. A short, friendly request works better than a lecture, and you can ask schools whether they have a social media sharing policy.

Talking to grandparents and relatives

Grandparents are usually your biggest fans, and the pride is real. Start with that. Then give them an easy alternative rather than just a rule.

Try: "We love that you share Sam's news. We're keeping his photos in our private family album now, so could you send them there instead of Facebook? And please leave his school and name out of captions."

Offer to set up the album for them, or send photos directly. Most relatives are happy to change when it is easy.

If your family uses a laptop for video calls with grandparents, a simple camera cover is a cheap extra habit that keeps the camera closed when no call is happening. Check that any cover is thin enough for your laptop to still close properly.

CloudValley Laptop Camera Cover Slide, Metal 0.023 Inch Ultra-Thin, 2 Packs

★★★★☆ 4.5 (55,323)
  • Privacy Protection: CloudValley webcam cover is designed for those who prioritize privacy, security, and…
  • Fashion Design: The space aluminum alloy webcam cover features a subtle design which compliments the…
  • Ultra-Thin Design: Measures only 0.023 (0.6 mm) inch thin, ensuring it does not interfere with closing your…

Schools, clubs and sports teams

Your child's photo may appear on a school website, a newsletter or a club page without you ever posting it. For schools and other organisations, you can ask if a social media sharing policy exists. If one does not, parents can offer to help create one.

Here is a message you can adapt: "Hi Ms Lee, could you tell me how the school handles photos on social media, and whether names ever appear with images? I'd love to understand the policy and help if there's anything I can do."

Read photo consent forms properly rather than ticking every box. You can usually say yes to some uses and no to others.

Birthday parties and playdates

Other children's parents have their own rules, and you may not know them. Group photos are a common problem.

Try: "I took a lovely group photo at the party. Are you happy for me to share it, or shall I just send it to you?"

When you and your partner disagree

One of you may post often, and the other may not want anything online. This is a very common difference, and it is not a sign that anyone is wrong. If it is causing tension, the relationship tips for parents in our guide can help you talk it through calmly.

Agree on three rules together, such as: nothing public, no school details, and ask the child first. Short rules are easier to remember than a long policy.

Common mistakes:

Posting a group photo without asking the other parents
Tagging other people's children
Assuming silence means yes
Telling relatives off in a comment instead of speaking privately

Up next: what to do about posts that are already out there.

What if I've already posted too much?

Don't panic, and don't beat yourself up. Most parents have posted something they would choose differently today. Audit what is online, remove what reveals too much, tighten your settings and bring your child into the process. A fresh start is always allowed.

A simple cleanup in four steps

  1. Audit. Scroll back through each account and note which posts are public. Look for school names, uniforms, locations, bath photos and embarrassing moments.
  2. Remove or archive. Take down the ones that reveal too much. Archiving keeps the memory without the audience.
  3. Tighten. Switch the account to private and remove followers you do not recognise.
  4. Tell your child. Say something like: "I tidied up some old pictures so fewer people can see them. You can tell me which ones you love and which ones you'd like gone."

Do not try to do it all in one evening. Spreading the work over short sessions each week is easier than doing it all at once.

Bringing your child into the process

UNICEF suggests parents can start bringing children from around 9 to 10 years into the process of going through social media feeds and deleting things. If your child is still young, you have time to prepare before they are old enough to help. Start by showing them photos and letting them point to the ones they love and the ones they dislike.

Prepare them for the future. Tell them: "Later on, when you're bigger, you'll help me decide what stays."

If you run a child account or earn money from content

Accounts dedicated to a child's daily life are a different level of sharing. Sharing personal information about a child without proper privacy protection can bring risks. Platform rules also change. For example, YouTube changed its Child Safety Policy to say that videos containing children may have some features disabled.

I will not tell you what to do with your income. I will ask you to consider whether your child would choose this, and what will happen when they are 13 and the archive is still online.

When to get help

A stranger messages your child, or messages you about your child
Your child's photos appear somewhere you did not post them
Someone is using your child's name or personal details
Your child is upset, teased or worried about something posted

If any of these happen, take screenshots, report the content on the platform and block the account. Tell your child's school if classmates are involved. If you feel your child may be at risk, contact the police or your local child protection service. Talk to your paediatrician if your child is distressed.

Some parents also want background on family law and parents' rights.

Comparing your sharing options

OptionBest Age RangePrimary BenefitsMain DrawbacksRecommended ProductPrice Range
Public accountNot a good fit at ages 5 to 8Wide reach and easy to findOpen to strangers, and details add upHow to Be Invisible$15.70
Private circle of family and close friendsAny age, with your child's sayKeeps the audience small and knownPeople can still screenshot or reshare5 Habits of the Tech Ready Family$6.50
Direct message or shared albumAny ageYou choose exactly who sees it, and it is easy for grandparentsTakes a little more effortCloudValley camera cover$6.99
Dedicated child accountNot recommended at ages 5 to 8Community and sometimes incomePrivacy risks, and your child has no sayChildren's Online Privacy Protection RulePrice not listed
Asking your child first, then choosingFrom about age 5Builds trust and teaches consentYour child may say noNO! I'M TELLING!Price not listed

Public posting can create risks like unwanted contact. Sharing a child's personal information without proper privacy protection can bring privacy risks.

Key Takeaways

  1. Sharing a photo now and then is not wrong, but it needs thought about audience and content.
  2. Names, school, location and any photo of a child in a state of nudity should stay out of public posts.
  3. Post later rather than live, and switch off location tagging.
  4. Ask your child first, using short, friendly words. Speak to your child before you post a photo or video of them online.
  5. Send relatives a short message with your rules and an invite to a private album, and ask schools about their policy.
  6. You can clean up old posts at any time, and from around 9 to 10 your child can help.
  7. If a stranger contacts your child or your child's photos appear elsewhere, screenshot, report, block and ask for help.

A final word

You want your child to feel loved and seen, and you want the people who love them to share in it. Both things can be true while you keep the audience small and your child in the loop.

Photos are one way we say "this moment mattered." What may matter most to your child is not the post, but that you asked them first and listened to the answer.

Parents who think before they post give their children something better than a perfect feed: a say in their own story. If this guide helped, save it for later, share it with a partner or a grandparent, and tell us what rules work in your home.

Sources & References

  1. American Academy of Pediatrics. "Sharing Photos and Videos of Children on Social Media ("Sharenting")."
  2. American Academy of Pediatrics. "Sharenting: 5 Questions to Ask Before You Post."
  3. American Academy of Pediatrics. "Child Exploitation Through Online Sharing: “Sharenting” and the Role of the Pediatric Provider."
  4. Childnet. "Answering parents most frequently asked questions about Instagram."
  5. Childnet. "Sharenting."
  6. UNICEF. "What you need to know about “sharenting”."
  7. NIH (National Library of Medicine). "Unanticipated Effects of Parental Social Media Use: Guidance for Clinicians."
  8. NIH (National Library of Medicine). "Examining antecedents of parents’ privacy concerns and mindful sharenting behaviors: through a lens of protection motivation theory."
  9. NIH (National Library of Medicine). "Sharenting: hidden pitfalls of a new increasing trend, suggestions on an appropriate use of social media."
  10. NIH (National Library of Medicine). "Development and Validation of the Sharenting Behavior Scale Among Parents."
  11. arXiv. "More Skin, More Likes! Measuring Child Exposure and User Engagement on TikTok."
  12. Internet Matters. "Sharenting tips for parents."
  13. Cleveland Clinic. "Sharing Isn’t Always Caring: The Risks and Dangers of ‘Sharenting’."

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it okay to post my child's photo at all?
Yes, for most families it can be fine. The American Academy of Pediatrics says sharing content of your family online isn't inherently bad or wrong, but it does need thoughtful consideration. Choose a small private audience, leave out names, school and location, and ask your child first. Public posting carries more risk of unwanted contact.
How many photos is too many?
There is no magic number, and no US clinical or legal guideline gives one. Parents have been found to share around 195 images of their children a year in one UK poll. Instead of counting, focus on audience and content. A few private photos to family are very different from daily public posts.
Can I post a first day of school photo?
You can, but think about what it shows. A first day of school picture can result in people knowing your child's name and where they attend school. Crop out the school name and uniform crest, skip the caption with their full name, and send it to a private family group instead.
My child says yes to every photo. Is that real consent?
Not fully. A young child does not understand what a lasting online footprint means, so you still make the final decision. Treat their yes as a good start. Say, "Thanks, I'll still keep your name and school out of it." That teaches them some details stay private.
Is there a law that stops me posting my child's photos?
It depends on where you live. In the US, COPPA prohibits online data collection without verifiable parental consent for children under 13, but that mainly applies to online services. No US clinical or legal guidelines exist for parents on safe sharing. Other countries set their own ages for digital consent.
When can my child help me delete old posts?
UNICEF suggests parents can start bringing children from around 9 to 10 years into the process of going through social media feeds and deleting things. Before then, you can prepare by showing your child photos and letting them point to the ones they love or dislike.

Was this helpful?

The Sunday Letter

One email a month.

Things we wish we’d known sooner — curated by parents, for parents.

One email a month. No spam, no sponsored fluff. Unsubscribe anytime.