Tiny Minds World

Daily Rhythms

Milk for Kids: Benefits and How to Choose the Right Type

TL;DR: Quick summaryFor most children, plain pasteurized cow's milk is the best everyday choice: whole milk from 12 months, then low fat (1%) or skim from age 2. Babies under 12 months stay on breast milk or formula. If your child cannot have dairy, unsweetened soy fortified with

By 33 min read
Milk for Kids: Benefits and How to Choose the Right Type
In this article

TL;DR: Quick summary

For most children, plain pasteurized cow's milk is the best everyday choice: whole milk from 12 months, then low fat (1%) or skim from age 2. Babies under 12 months stay on breast milk or formula. If your child cannot have dairy, unsweetened soy fortified with calcium and vitamin D is the closest swap.

Babies under 12 months should not drink cow's milk, plain, flavored or plant based.
Toddlers aged 1 to 2 do well on whole milk, about 2 to 3 cups a day at most, and too much can crowd out iron rich foods.
From age 2, switch to plain low fat or skim, and skip flavored milk in the early years.
Always choose pasteurized milk, never raw.

What you'll get

A clear answer on which milk fits your child's age, from newborn to teen
Simple daily amounts, plus word for word scripts for picky eaters, grandparents and teens
A safe plan if your child cannot drink cow's milk, including which plant drinks to skip

About 27 minutes to read. Short on time? Read the bold lines and the Key Takeaways near the end.

It is a Tuesday evening and your child has just turned one. The fridge holds whole milk, a neighbor swears by oat milk, a friend says goat milk is gentler, and your own mother is sure a toddler needs milk "to grow big and strong." You just want to know which carton to put in the cart.

This guide is for parents and caregivers of children from birth to the teen years. It explains what milk does for growing bodies, which type fits each age, how much is enough, and what to do when milk is not an option. By the end you will be able to read a carton label with confidence and answer the people who have opinions about your choices.

I write this the way I talk to parents in clinic. There is no perfect milk, only a good fit for your child's age, health and tastes.

Why is milk good for kids, and do they actually need it?

Milk packs calcium, protein, vitamin D and energy into one easy drink, which is why it has stayed a staple for growing children. But no child needs milk itself. They need what is in it, and for most families milk is the simplest, cheapest way to get there.

What milk gives a growing body

Calcium is the headline. Children build bone quickly, and the childhood and teen years are when the body stores up the bone it will rely on for decades. Milk is one of the easiest foods to get calcium from, and it comes packaged with protein and, in many cartons, added vitamin D, which helps the body use that calcium.

Protein supports growth, muscle and the daily repair of scrapes and bumps. A Canadian pediatric source notes that two cups of cow milk (16 grams of protein) or two cups of fortified soy beverage (13 grams of protein) pretty well meet a child's protein needs. That is a lot of nutrition in a small amount of liquid.

Milk also brings fat and carbohydrate for energy, and a glass with a meal tends to keep a child fuller for longer. It counts toward fluids too, although plain water is still the everyday drink between meals.

Milk is a tool, not a requirement

Children who cannot drink milk, or simply refuse it, can still grow well. Yogurt, cheese, fortified alternatives and a varied diet fill the gap, and I will show you how in the later sections. What matters is the pattern across a week, not one glass on one day.

Picture a four year old who drinks one cup of milk at breakfast, eats yogurt at snack time and has cheese on pasta. That child is probably getting plenty of dairy nutrition, even if dinner is a battle. Dairy does not have to arrive in a glass.

Common mistakes with milk

Treating milk as a meal replacement for a child who skips food
Letting a child sip milk from a bottle or cup all day
Assuming that more milk means faster growth
Paying extra for added features your child does not need

When to talk to your doctor

Mention it to your pediatrician if your child is growing slowly, gets constant tummy trouble after milk, or refuses all dairy and most other calcium sources. They can check growth and build a plan with you. Do not cut out whole food groups on your own if symptoms are puzzling you.

Up next: Babies come first, because the rules for the first year are the strictest.

When can babies start cow's milk, and what do they drink before that?

Cow's milk as a regular drink waits until 12 months old, and not before. Until then your baby's drink is breast milk or infant formula. Plain, flavored and plant based milks are all off the list for babies under one.

Why the line is drawn at 12 months

The CDC puts it simply:

The same page says milk alternatives, such as soy or oat drinks, should also wait until 12 months. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) agrees that children under 12 months should not consume milk of any kind, whether plain, flavored or plant based.

In the first year, breast milk or formula does the heavy lifting because both are made for a baby's body. Cow's milk is a fine drink for an older child, but it is not built to be a baby's main food. If you are wondering about yogurt or cheese before the first birthday, ask your doctor or health visitor what suits your baby.

What is normal around the first birthday

Around this age most babies are eating solid food several times a day and getting more curious about cups. You will see this in the baby's development milestones, such as holding things, copying you and wanting to feed themselves. A small cup of water with a meal fits right in.

If you are breastfeeding, you can keep going for as long as you and your baby want, and sips of water from a cup are an addition rather than a replacement. If you are using formula, ask your doctor how quickly to phase it out. Every baby's appetite and growth is a little different.

Making the switch, step by step

  1. Wait until your baby is 12 months old. Put the date in your phone so a well meaning relative does not jump the gun.
  2. Buy plain, unflavored whole milk that says pasteurized on the label.
  3. Offer a few sips in a small cup at a meal. Do not expect a full cup on day one.
  4. Keep breast milk or formula going alongside while your child's appetite adjusts, as your doctor advises.
  5. Move bottles toward cups gradually, and watch for any rash, vomiting or swelling after the first taste. If that happens, stop and call your doctor, and ask them in advance what should send you to emergency care.

What to say to relatives

If someone offers your baby a splash of milk "just to try," a calm script helps: "She turns one soon. Until then it is formula only, and after that we are starting plain whole milk in a cup. Thank you for checking."

You do not have to explain more than that. Most grandparents just want a rule they can follow.

Stretching formula with cow's milk before 12 months to save money
Choosing a plant based drink because it sounds healthier
Offering sweetened or flavored milk as the first taste
Putting milk in a bottle at bedtime as a sleep prop

When to get help

Talk to your doctor before the first birthday if you have a family history of milk allergy or your baby has had a reaction to dairy foods or to formula. They may want to guide the first introduction. Also ask if your baby is not gaining weight well or seems to dislike every drink you offer.

Up next: Once milk is on the menu, how much does a one year old need, and should it be whole?

How much milk does a one year old need, and should it be whole?

Most children aged 1 to 2 should drink whole milk, about 2 to 3 cups (16 to 24 ounces) a day at most, depending on how much solid food they eat. More than that can leave no room for iron rich foods.

Why whole milk for toddlers

Toddlers are small people with big energy needs, and whole milk gives calories and fat in a drink that comes with calcium and protein. Most kids under age 2 should drink whole milk. The fat helps young children, who have small stomachs and cannot eat huge meals, get enough energy.

There is one important exception. If a toddler is overweight or there is a family history of obesity, high cholesterol or heart problems, your doctor might recommend switching to reduced fat (2%) milk. That is a decision for your doctor, not something to do on your own.

The iron problem nobody warns you about

Milk fills little tummies fast. Limiting your child's milk to 16 to 24 ounces a day matters because too much cow's milk can fill kids up so they have no room for foods rich in iron.

Picture a toddler who is handed a cup of milk whenever she looks fussy. By dinner she has had far more than she needs and she pushes the plate away. The solution is not to ban milk but to pace it.

How much counts toward the total?

Different groups give slightly different ranges. The AAP says 2 to 3 cups a day of whole milk until age 2, with individual needs depending on how much solid food a child eats. US dietary guidance for dairy under 2 years is 1 and 2/3 to 2 cups a day, and that includes yogurt and cheese as well as milk.

In practice, think of about two cups of dairy as the target for a typical toddler. Count yogurt and cheese in that total. Go higher only if your doctor agrees, and go lower if your child is eating plenty of dairy foods.

Horizon Organic, Milk Whole Growing Years Organic, 59 Fl Oz

★★★★☆ 4.8 (2,070)
  • Organic Whole Milk for Kids: One 59 fl oz carton of Horizon Organic Growing Years DHA Omega-3 Whole Milk…
  • DHA Supports Brain Health: DHA whole milk provides 50mg DHA Omega-3 per serving, which helps support brain…
  • Developed with Pediatricians: Horizon Organic Growing Years Whole Milk was developed with pediatricians and…

A plain whole milk carton is the baseline the guidelines describe. If you like the idea of added extras, Horizon Organic Growing Years whole milk is a familiar choice. The listing says it has DHA per serving and was developed with pediatricians, but treat those as nice extras, not requirements, and compare the price with plain whole milk.

Toddler milk drinks and goat milk

You will see tubs marketed as toddler milk, including goat milk options such as Kabrita Goat Milk Toddler Drink. The AAP is clear on this one:

Toddler milk is not recommended; nutrient needs should be met primarily through nutritionally adequate dietary patterns.

American Academy of Pediatrics

In plain words, a balanced diet plus plain milk does the job, and a special drink is a choice, not a need. If you are drawn to goat milk, talk to your pediatrician first. If your child has a cow's milk allergy, ask your doctor before trying goat milk.

Practical routine for a one year old

  1. Offer food first, then milk with the meal, so milk does not fill the tummy before the food does.
  2. Serve water between meals and snacks.
  3. Use an open cup or a straw cup, and read about the cup you choose if you are unsure.
  4. Count yogurt and cheese toward the daily dairy total.

If you are heading to daycare, try a small pack such as six Horizon Organic shelf stable whole milk boxes before buying a big one, to see whether your child likes them.

What if my toddler refuses milk?

Many toddlers go off milk, and it is rarely a crisis. Try a calm script: "You do not have to drink it, but milk is what we have with lunch. Water is for in between." Then move on without a fuss.

Offer yogurt, cheese or milk in a cooked dish such as oatmeal or a smoothie made with plain milk. If your child refuses all dairy for weeks, ask your doctor about other calcium sources. For picky eating in general, see the picky eater guide.

Giving milk at every request, which crowds out food
Using milk as a sleep aid or a pacifier
Switching to 2% or skim before age 2 without your doctor's advice
Treating a toddler milk tub as an upgrade over plain whole milk

Up next: What changes at age 2, and which fat level should you choose from then on?

Which milk is best from age 2 to 5?

At 2, most children move to plain, pasteurized low fat (1%) or skim milk. The AAP says total milk can be up to 2 cups a day for ages 2 to 3 and up to 2.5 cups a day for ages 4 to 5.

Why the switch at age 2

By age 2, children eat a wider range of foods, and the AAP advises moving them from whole milk to lower fat milk. The AAP advises that at 2 years, children should transition to plain, pasteurized fat free (skim) or low fat (1%) milk. Lower fat milk keeps the calcium and protein while trimming some calories and saturated fat.

There are real exceptions. If your child is small for age, growing slowly or has a medical condition, ask your doctor before switching. Some children do better staying on whole milk for a while.

How to make the switch without a fuss

Children notice taste changes, so go slowly.

  1. Start by mixing half whole and half 1%, then shift the balance gradually.
  2. Move to mostly 1% with a splash of whole, then to 1% alone.
  3. Serve it cold and in the same cup, so the only change is the milk.
  4. Stay calm and neutral. Do not announce that the new milk is "healthier."

How much milk per day at this age

For ages 2 to 3, total milk can be up to 2 cups (16 ounces) a day, and for ages 4 to 5 up to 2.5 cups (20 ounces). For ages 2 through 8, US guidance suggests 2 to 2.5 cups of dairy a day, which includes yogurt and cheese.

Think of these as upper limits, not targets. A child who also eats yogurt and cheese may not need that much milk.

What about flavored milk?

Flavored milk is the hardest one to say no to. The CDC advises choosing milk that is unflavored and unsweetened, because flavored cow's milk and fortified dairy alternatives can have added sugars, and your child does not need added sugars.

The AAP adds that children aged 2 to 5 should avoid flavored milk to limit added sugar and avoid developing a preference for sweet tastes. That second point is the one I stress with parents. Taste habits form early, and once a child expects every drink to be sweet, plain milk loses.

For a preschooler who asks, try: "Today we have white milk with dinner. Chocolate milk is for special days, like birthday parties."

Daycare and preschool

Some childcare centers serve milk at meals, so check what guidance they follow. Ask which fat level they serve and whether they offer plain milk only. If your child is under 2, make sure the center knows to serve whole milk.

Skipping the switch at age 2 because "whole milk is more natural"
Offering strawberry or chocolate milk daily to get a child to drink more
Letting milk replace meals for a child who "does not eat anything"
Switching fat levels without watching how your child's weight and appetite are doing

When to get help

Ask your doctor if your child is losing weight, if tummy trouble follows milk, or if you are worried about calcium because milk is not an option. Also ask if your family has a history of high cholesterol, since fat advice can vary.

Up next: Beyond age 5, what role does milk play for school age kids and teens?

What about milk for school age kids and teens?

For ages 2 through 8, US guidance suggests 2 to 2.5 cups of dairy a day, and milk can supply most of it. Older kids and teens need more as they grow, so ask your doctor or dietitian what amount fits your child.

The school age years, about 5 to 12

By school age, children are eating more varied foods and choosing for themselves at lunch. Milk is still a handy source of calcium and protein, but it is one of several options. If dinner includes yogurt or cheese, a second glass of milk may not be needed.

Lunchboxes bring a practical question. Boxes of shelf stable milk are convenient for lunchboxes, and you can check the listing for Horizon Organic shelf stable whole milk boxes for fat content and nutrition details.

One caution: these are whole milk. Since the AAP advises low fat or skim from age 2, whole milk boxes are mainly a convenience pick for children whose doctor wants extra calories. For most school age children, look at the fat percentage on any box you buy and treat full fat as an occasional choice.

Milk and the picky eater

It is common for a school age child to live on milk and a few favorite foods. That is worth gently addressing, because milk can fill the tummy and push out other foods. For a deeper look at normal fussiness and what helps, read the picky eater guide, and keep milk to meals.

A useful script: "We have milk with dinner. If you are still hungry afterward, there is fruit or toast." This sets a rule without making dinner a debate.

Sports, snacks and after school

After sports, many kids reach for a sugary sports drink. Plain milk is a more nutritious choice for most children, giving fluid, protein and calcium. Water is still the best everyday thirst quencher.

If your child has a post practice snack, try milk with a banana or a plain yogurt. It is quick and does not need a label reading session.

Teens: bones are still being built

Bones keep growing through the teen years, so calcium stays important well past childhood. Teens, though, drink less milk than younger children, and often swap it for soda, energy drinks or sugary coffee drinks. For a firm number for your teen, ask your doctor or a dietitian, because needs depend on age, growth and activity.

If your teen says "I hate milk," try a calm approach: "Fine, but let's find another way to get calcium. Yogurt, cheese, a smoothie made with plain milk, or fortified soy all count." Then let them choose.

Flavored milk is where I draw my own line. In my practice I treat it as occasional rather than a daily habit, because of the added sugar the CDC warns about.

Red flags worth a conversation

If a teen suddenly cuts out dairy plus many other foods, or talks a lot about "clean eating," mention it to your doctor. Often there is a simple reason, such as lactose trouble, but sometimes it signals something that needs support.

Offer milk or a calcium source at meals
Keep plain milk and yogurt stocked at home
Check how much sugar is in the coffee and drinks your teen buys
Ask your doctor if your teen avoids all dairy
Letting flavored milk or sugary drinks replace plain milk every day
Using milk as the main "meal" after school
Arguing with a teen about milk at the table

Up next: What to do when cow's milk is not an option, and which alternatives to avoid.

What if my child can't drink cow's milk?

If your child can't have cow's milk, unsweetened soy drink fortified with calcium and vitamin D is the closest swap. Most other plant drinks are not nutritionally equal to cow's milk, and some are risky for young children.

Lactose intolerance versus milk allergy

These two get mixed up all the time, so let me separate them. Lactose intolerance means the body has trouble digesting lactose, the sugar in milk, which causes bloating, gas and loose stools. Milk allergy is an immune reaction to the proteins in milk, and it can be serious.

Lactose free cow's milk is still real cow's milk, with the same protein and calcium, but without the lactose. That makes it a good fit for a child with lactose trouble. It is not safe for a child with a milk allergy, because the milk protein is still there.

If you suspect an allergy, see your doctor before you try anything else. Signs can include belly pain, nausea, vomiting or diarrhea after milk. Ask your doctor to give you a written plan and to explain what should send you to emergency care.

Plant drinks: what the evidence says

The AAP says plant milks and other nondairy drinks are not recommended as the only drink in place of dairy milk for children aged 1 to 5, with the exception of soy milk. They should be used only when medically needed or to meet a specific dietary preference.

The AAP also reminds parents that most plant based milks are not nutritionally equal to cow's milk and may be low in protein, vitamin D and calcium. That is why soy gets a special mention.

If your child can’t drink cow’s milk, choose unsweetened soy drinks fortified with calcium and vitamin D.

KidsHealth

Protein is a good example of the gap. Two cups of cow milk give about 16 grams of protein, and two cups of fortified soy beverage give about 13 grams. Many other plant drinks have less, so check the label.

Two plant drinks to be careful with

Rice drinks: children under 5 should not have rice drinks as a substitute for breast milk, infant formula or cow's milk, because they may contain too much arsenic.
Almond drinks: almond based drinks may contain aflatoxins and, according to the German risk agency BfR, should not be regularly given to children under 6.

They just should not be everyday drinks for young children.

Choosing a plant drink: a quick checklist

Unsweetened, because flavored and sweetened versions add sugar
Fortified with calcium and vitamin D
Soy for most young children who cannot have cow's milk
A drink the doctor or dietitian has approved if your child has allergies

What a dietitian will probably ask

If your child is on a plant drink for a medical reason, a dietitian can check the whole diet. They will look at protein, calcium, vitamin D, iron and calories across the day. They may suggest a supplement. Read about kids' vitamins first and ask your doctor before starting one.

Picture a child with a confirmed milk allergy who eats a varied diet with fortified soy, calcium rich foods and a doctor approved plan. That child can grow well. The key is the plan, not the carton.

Scripts for other adults

If a caregiver wonders why your child gets a different drink: "She cannot have cow's milk, so she has unsweetened fortified soy. Please do not swap it for almond or rice, and let me know if she gets any rash or tummy trouble."

Up next: How to buy, store and serve milk safely at home and on the go.

How do I choose and serve milk safely at home and on the go?

Choose plain, pasteurized milk in a form you will actually use. Never give raw milk. Shelf stable boxes and powders are handy for travel and daycare if you keep to the same rules on age, fat and sweetness.

Pasteurized, always

The CDC is blunt about raw milk:

Raw milk and raw milk products from cows, goats, and sheep can carry harmful bacteria and other germs.

CDC

These germs can make a child very sick and can be life threatening, so do not give your child raw or unpasteurized milk. Raw milk is especially risky for young children, children with medical conditions and pregnant people, and pasteurized milk is the safest choice for children.

Picture a family visiting a farm stand on a lovely weekend. The farmer offers a fresh sample, and it looks harmless. Your script is easy: "Thank you, but we only do pasteurized milk with the kids." That is all you need to say.

Shelf stable boxes and powder for travel

Shelf stable boxes are a practical choice for lunch boxes, road trips and daycare when the label says pasteurized and the milk is plain. They are useful for lunch boxes, road trips and daycare. Compare the 18 box pack with the smaller pack to see which suits you.

For travel, powdered milk can save a lot of weight. Voyager organic whole milk powder sachets are a travel option, so check the label for the full ingredient list. The listing says you add water and shake.

Voyager Toddler Milk On The Go, USDA Organic Shelf Stable Whole Milk Powder, Great for Travel, No Refrigeration, Gluten Free with No GMO's and No Antibiotics for Kids, 16 Sachets of 15g

★★★★☆ 4.4 (373)
  • TRAVEL TODDLER ESSENTIALS: Voyager Milk is your go-to toddler travel milk for families on the move. These…
  • PEDIATRICIAN-DEVELOPED FORMULA: Trusted by parents and doctors alike, our toddler milk is created with only 3…
  • NO REFRIGERATION, NO PROBLEM: Our whole milk powder packets are TSA-approved and shelf stable. Just add 4 oz…

Because it is a whole milk powder, it is for children aged 12 months and older, not for babies, and it is not infant formula. Follow the pack directions for mixing, and use clean water and a clean cup.

A larger tub such as Horizon Organic Instant Dry Whole Milk is a pantry and emergency item more than a daily drink. The listing says it works for baking and cooking and can be mixed with water as the pack directs. At its price, it is more than most families need for everyday use.

Serving milk at home

  1. Offer milk with meals, and water between them.
  2. Use an open cup or a straw cup rather than a bottle, from the first birthday on.
  3. Pour a small amount at a time so you do not waste a full cup.
  4. Keep milk in the fridge, and follow the dates and storage instructions on the carton.
  5. Brush teeth after the last drink at night, and do not let a child fall asleep with a milk cup.

A quick shopping checklist

Plain, with no flavors or added sugar
The word pasteurized on the label
The right fat level for your child's age: whole from 12 months, low fat or skim from 2
For plant drinks, unsweetened and fortified with calcium and vitamin D
A size you will finish before the date

Common safety mistakes

Offering raw or unpasteurized milk because it seems more natural
Leaving milk out on the counter or in a warm car
Using powder meant for older children for a baby under 12 months
Assuming "organic" or "natural" means safe for every age

When to get help

Call your doctor if your child has vomiting, diarrhea, fever or any other illness after drinking milk. Mention what milk was served and whether it was pasteurized. For allergic signs after milk, ask your doctor in advance what should send you straight to emergency care.

Milk options compared

Here is a quick view of the products mentioned in this guide, with loose age ranges. Whole milk from 12 months comes from CDC guidance.

OptionBest Age RangePrimary BenefitsMain DrawbacksRecommended ProductPrice Range
Whole milk cartonFrom about 12 months to 2 yearsPlain whole milk with calcium, protein and added DHA per the listingAdded DHA is optional; compare the price with plain whole milkHorizon Organic Growing Years whole milk$5.99 for 59 fl oz
Shelf stable milk boxesFrom about 12 monthsGrab and go, no fridge until opened, 8 g protein per box per the listingWhole milk, so a convenience choice after age 2Horizon Organic whole milk boxes, 18 pack$19.48 for 18 boxes
Whole milk powder sachetsFrom about 12 monthsLight and easy for travel, three ingredients per the listingNot for babies; higher cost per servingVoyager whole milk powder sachets$31.99 for 16 sachets
Goat milk toddler drinkAbout 12 to 24 monthsMaker lists many quality checks and a goat milk baseAAP does not recommend toddler milk; not a fix for cow's milk allergyKabrita Goat Milk Toddler Drink$42.99 for 28 oz
Dry whole milk canisterPantry, baking and emergency useLong shelf life and 50% more calcium than standard dry whole milk per the listingCostly for everyday drinkingHorizon Organic Instant Dry Whole Milk$160.00 for 30.6 oz

The AAP does not recommend toddler milk drinks, so talk over any such product with your pediatrician before offering it.

Frequently asked questions

Key Takeaways

  1. Babies under 12 months should not drink cow's milk or milk alternatives; breast milk or formula is the drink until the first birthday.
  2. From 12 months, plain whole milk is the usual choice, up to 2 to 3 cups a day, and milk should not crowd out iron rich foods.
  3. At age 2, most children move to plain low fat (1%) or skim milk, and flavored milk should be limited.
  4. Toddler milk drinks are not recommended, so a balanced diet plus plain milk is enough.
  5. If your child cannot have cow's milk, unsweetened soy fortified with calcium and vitamin D is the closest swap, and rice and almond drinks need care in young children.
  6. Always choose pasteurized milk and never raw.
  7. Milk is a tool, not a requirement: calcium, protein and vitamin D can come from other foods too.

The simple version

Choosing milk should not feel like an exam. Match the milk to your child's age, keep it plain, serve it with meals, and let water do the rest of the work. The right carton is the one that fits your child, your budget and your routine.

If you remember one thing, make it this: milk is a helper, not a hero. Save this guide for the next time a relative, a label or a toddler tests your resolve, and share it with the other adults who help care for your child.

Sources & References

  1. CDC. "Cow's Milk and Milk Alternatives."
  2. American Academy of Pediatrics. "Healthy Beverage Quick Reference Guide."
  3. MedlinePlus. "Cow's milk and children: MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia."
  4. KidsHealth. "Feeding at 1 to 2 Years."
  5. American Academy of Pediatrics. "Recommended Drinks for Children Age 5 & Younger."
  6. Children's Hospital of Philadelphia. "What type of milk should my child drink?"
  7. NHS. "Drinks and cups for babies and young children."
  8. NIH National Library of Medicine. "Plant-Based Drinks as an Alternative to Cow’s Milk in Early Life: Health Effects in Infancy, Childhood, and Adolescence."
  9. Canadian Paediatric Society. "Dietitians, paediatricians advise parents to exercise caution with plant-based beverages."

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my baby have cow's milk before 12 months?
No. The CDC says whole cow's milk can be introduced at 12 months old, but not before, and the AAP says children under 12 months should not consume milk of any kind, including flavored and plant based. Until the first birthday, breast milk or infant formula is the drink. If you have questions about dairy foods such as yogurt, ask your doctor.
Is whole milk or 2% better for my toddler?
For most children under 2, whole milk is the right choice. If a toddler is overweight or there is a family history of obesity, high cholesterol or heart problems, a doctor might recommend 2% milk. At age 2, the AAP advises moving to plain low fat (1%) or skim milk. Do not switch early without talking to your doctor.
How much milk is too much for a toddler?
The AAP recommends 2 to 3 cups (16 to 24 ounces) of whole milk a day until age 2, depending on how much solid food your child eats. KidsHealth suggests limiting milk to 16 to 24 ounces a day, because too much can fill kids up and crowd out iron rich foods. If your child is drinking more, cut back to within that range.
Is chocolate or strawberry milk okay for kids?
It is best avoided for young children, since flavored milk can carry added sugars. The CDC says to choose unflavored, unsweetened milk because flavored versions can have added sugars. The AAP says children aged 2 to 5 should avoid flavored milk to limit added sugar and avoid developing a preference for sweet tastes. For older kids, keep it occasional too.
Are oat, almond or rice drinks good swaps for cow's milk?
Usually not for young children. The AAP says plant milks are not recommended as the only drink in place of dairy milk, with the exception of soy. Rice drinks are not advised for children under 5, and almond based drinks should not be regularly given to children under 6. Unsweetened fortified soy is the closest swap.
Is raw milk healthier for children?
No. Raw milk from cows, goats and sheep can carry harmful bacteria and other germs that can make a child very sick, and the CDC says not to give your child raw or unpasteurized milk. Pasteurized milk is the safest choice for children, especially young ones and those with medical conditions.
Does my toddler need a special toddler milk?
No. The AAP does not recommend toddler milk, and says nutrient needs should be met primarily through a nutritionally adequate diet. Plain whole milk from 12 months, plus a varied diet, usually does the job. If you want to use one for a specific reason, talk to your pediatrician first.

Was this helpful?

The Sunday Letter

One email a month.

Things we wish we’d known sooner — curated by parents, for parents.

One email a month. No spam, no sponsored fluff. Unsubscribe anytime.